Best Actress: Kate Winslet
Did you know that an illiterate Nazi is still a Nazi?
Cause it worries me that that's not the focus of this film, it seems to be treated as something equally as shameful. And yes, I know there are probably millions of illiterate people around the world at this very moment who feel great shame in that fact but I'm reliably convinced that more than 90% of them aren't f*cking Nazis, too.Anyway, the crux of this film is that Kate plays Hanna Schmitz, a German woman who's secretive and engaging in an affair with a 15-year-old boy (which is yikes on bikes on its own), and who is later revealed to have been a Nazi guard who let 300 Jewish people die in a church fire. You're supposed to feel bad for her because she was just following orders and because she's illiterate and unwilling to reveal this information, which would slightly exonerate her, because her other Nazi hags are framing her for ordering the murder when they all in reality shared equal blame.
Since when is admitting you're illiterate more shameful than admitting that you're a Nazi who was following orders? She couldn't hear the screaming? She didn't see with her own eyes what was happening? She needed a job, she tells the court, but like, go do literally anything else rather than be a Nazi!
Kate, I wish you'd been nominated for Revolutionary Road. It was the better film and the better performance.
Kate was nominated against Anne Hathaway (Rachel Getting Married), Angelina Jolie (Changeling), Melissa Leo (Frozen River), and Meryl Streep (Doubt).
Ugh. This is very obviously a career Oscar, despite how sad and restrained she is throughout this film, and I'm so sad that it was for The Reader.
DID I LIKE THE READER? Fuck no.
__
Did you like The Reader? What are your thoughts on Kate Winslet's Oscar win?
Keep up with all my Rewatching the Best Actresses posts here.

Comments
Post a Comment